skip to Main Content

Book Review: Begley’s Why the Dreyfus Affair Matters

This install­ment in our ongo­ing series of book reviews takes on Why the Drey­fus Affair Mat­ters by lawyer/novelist Louis Beg­ley.  Hugh Murtaugh’s com­pli­men­ta­ry review of Begley’s work inter­twines the Drey­fus and the Guan­tanamo nar­ra­tives.  Both Beg­ley and this review­er con­clude with the same lament from Proust: “As for ask­ing one­self about its val­ue, not one thought of it now .… It was no longer shock­ing. That was all that was required.”

By Hugh K. Murtagh

The sto­ry of Guan­tanamo Bay is not over. Pres­i­dent Oba­ma will not be able to shut­ter the island prison until at least 2011, and then only by mov­ing the remain­ing detainees to a state­side facil­i­ty. Time pass­es, details emerge: the “Camp Delta Stan­dard Oper­at­ing Pro­ce­dures” find their way onto the inter­net; a mil­i­tary judge will not allow the pros­e­cu­tion of a ter­ror­ist leader because he has been so bad­ly abused; Sami al-Hajj, the al-Jazeera jour­nal­ist held for years on chang­ing unsub­stan­ti­at­ed charges, is final­ly released to Sudan, with his diaries.

Read More

Book Review: The Least Worst Place (Karen Greenberg)

Con­tin­u­ing with the theme of armed con­flict, deten­tion, and ter­ror­ism, the lat­est install­ment in our occa­sion­al series of book reviews address­es Karen Greenberg’s The Least Worst Place: Guantanamo’s First 100 DaysThis review may also be found in Issue 42:3 of the Jour­nal of Inter­na­tion­al Law and Pol­i­tics.

By John Wun­der­lin

In the pref­ace to The Least Worst Place: Guantanamo’s First 100 Days, Karen Green­berg briefly sets out the aim of the book: to describe the ear­ly days of the Guan­tanamo Bay deten­tion facil­i­ty, in which few abus­es occurred despite incred­i­bly try­ing cir­cum­stances, and to ask whether this nar­ra­tive sheds any light on how lat­er abus­es came to occur and how such abus­es might be avoid­ed in the future. Per­haps in def­er­ence to the com­plex­i­ty and dif­fi­cul­ty of the sub­ject, Green­berg nev­er tries to for­mu­late the lessons as a set of pol­i­cy pre­scrip­tions. Nev­er­the­less, she suc­ceeds in devel­op­ing a strong under­stand­ing of how cer­tain forces and cir­cum­stances gath­ered to cre­ate a dis­as­ter at Guan­tanamo while oth­er forces worked to keep dis­as­ter at bay.

Read More
Back To Top
Search